Thoughts on The Bhagavad Gita (Chapter 2: Verse 21 - Verse 25)

WEBVTT

00:00:03.081 --> 00:00:09.321
Hello and welcome to The Bearded Mystic Podcast and I'm your host Rahul N Singh.

00:00:09.711 --> 00:00:16.431
Thank you for taking out the time today to join and listen, or watch this podcast episode.

00:00:16.548 --> 00:00:30.035
If you would like to support The Bearded Mystic Podcast and keep it ad free, you can sign up to my Patreon page and I will leave the details in the show notes and video description below.

00:00:30.211 --> 00:00:37.319
Now we shall begin with my thoughts on the Bhagavad Gita, starting off with verse 21.

00:00:37.848 --> 00:00:43.249
The true self is indestructible, timeless, and is neither born nor dies.

00:00:43.420 --> 00:00:51.119
So, then tell me Arjuna, how is that purusha going to be slain, and who is able to kill them?

00:00:52.368 --> 00:00:58.728
So, this is really a summary of what's already been established in verses 16 to 20.

00:00:58.997 --> 00:01:14.233
Please do take a look at the previous episode, it was one hour long and we went into each and every verse in great depth, do revisit that if you want to understand more about what's going to happen.

00:01:15.433 --> 00:01:30.911
But Krishna wants to make sure that the receptive Arjuna grasps the understanding that's required, because the one thing that we definitely need in spirituality is repetitive education, repetitive knowledge.

00:01:31.284 --> 00:01:39.061
Without this type of repetition, we're not able to advance further, or we're not able to fully understand something.

00:01:39.203 --> 00:01:44.713
For example, when you read something, are you just reading to understand it or you reading just to get to the next page?

00:01:45.177 --> 00:01:56.100
The same here, are you reading the verse to get to the next verse or are you taking your time to understand the message and understand the theory.

00:01:56.189 --> 00:02:10.356
This true self, the Atma or Brahman that we often refer to here as the ultimate reality, that is indestructible, that is timeless and that neither is born and neither does it die.

00:02:10.524 --> 00:02:16.209
Just a reminder that I'll be using Atman and Brahman interchangeably.

00:02:16.258 --> 00:02:20.209
If you ever hear me say Atman, I'm talking about Brahman.

00:02:20.598 --> 00:02:30.502
If after hearing this message, we still believe that we are bounded by time, or we can be destroyed or that we have taken birth or will one day die.

00:02:30.772 --> 00:02:33.143
We still believe we are this body and mind.

00:02:33.353 --> 00:02:35.633
That's how simple the understanding is.

00:02:35.862 --> 00:02:58.330
That if right now, despite Shri Krishna really going into the spiritual wisdom about how we are eternal, how the dehi, the inner dweller is eternal and that the deha, the body is nothing but subject to modification, subject to birth and death.

00:02:58.360 --> 00:03:03.850
If we still haven't accepted this, then what is left to understand?

00:03:04.251 --> 00:03:06.200
We need to start understanding this.

00:03:06.450 --> 00:03:17.397
When we start believing that with the body of mind, then we are always all going to be attracted and also harmed by its associations.

00:03:17.397 --> 00:03:23.187
For example, if we believed we're this body and mind, if there's an ache in the body, we're constantly going to feel that ache.

00:03:23.514 --> 00:03:32.038
If you believe we are the mind, we constantly going to be worried about things, anxious about things and even our happiness is fleeting.

00:03:32.394 --> 00:03:47.424
We have to understand that this message is about understanding that it is only the body and the mind that comes into existence and then departs from existence.

00:03:47.820 --> 00:03:58.584
But it is this Brahman, the Inner Dweller, that is continuously here, it is the Sat , remember the Ultimate Reality that does not change.

00:03:59.723 --> 00:04:01.074
This always exists.

00:04:01.493 --> 00:04:06.503
This being unborn and undying, it is eternal.

00:04:06.924 --> 00:04:09.984
Therefore it is the only thing that is true.

00:04:10.264 --> 00:04:13.713
We obviously still believe in the finite aspect of our existence.

00:04:14.718 --> 00:04:17.449
So then can we claim to be knowers of the truth?

00:04:17.713 --> 00:04:23.413
Can we claim to know the true self can we claim to know the art mama?

00:04:23.622 --> 00:04:29.786
Can we claim to know Brahman can we claim to know what we perceive to be god?

00:04:30.362 --> 00:04:35.103
Can we say that we are true knowers of This?

00:04:36.333 --> 00:04:49.673
I don't think we can, if we still believe we're this body and mind and this is what Sri Krishna is telling Arjuna that, tell me, how is that Purusha going to be slain, how is that Inner Dweller going to be slain?

00:04:50.541 --> 00:05:03.995
Then we have a question that's raised by Shri Krishna that if the Atman is indestructable and timeless, then how is that very being, going to be slain and who is able to kill them?

00:05:04.786 --> 00:05:12.062
Well, who can kill the elders, the mentors, the gurus that are in front of him, his brothers that are in front of him.

00:05:12.422 --> 00:05:13.291
Who can kill them?

00:05:13.322 --> 00:05:16.471
If this Purusha doesn't die?

00:05:17.353 --> 00:05:27.634
Shri Krishna goes on to say that basically how can one try to destroy something that is indestructible and timeless?

00:05:28.273 --> 00:05:38.817
Very clear here by Shri Krishna, he's just reemphasizing the point and trying to get Arjuna to get out of his moment of sorrow and delusion.

00:05:39.331 --> 00:05:52.105
Also to note here that mentions that the act of killing has been cited as an example, the larger context to be understood is that it is in regards to all forms of action itself.

00:05:52.264 --> 00:06:03.528
Even though in the context of this, it's talking about killing and being slain, but the real purpose is to understand that action that we are not the doers of action.

00:06:04.088 --> 00:06:08.829
The larger question is, does a person of realization commit any action?

00:06:08.918 --> 00:06:21.583
That's what we want to understand and Adi Sankara ji further states that once a person is realized, they no longer need to perform ritualistic actions because they become free from it.

00:06:22.028 --> 00:06:26.468
He specifically says they no longer identify as a doer anymore.

00:06:26.577 --> 00:06:32.228
So who will reap the benefits of such activities and who will reap the detriment of such activities?

00:06:32.790 --> 00:06:35.250
Who is the person that's going to gain anything?

00:06:35.641 --> 00:06:42.930
If you believe that you are the dehi, the Inner Dweller, how is that going to benefit from the ritualistic actions you do?

00:06:43.110 --> 00:06:47.127
How is that going to benefit from the deeds that you do?

00:06:47.254 --> 00:06:53.994
How is that going to be affected or at the detriment of deeds that cause harm to others.

00:06:54.254 --> 00:06:56.783
The dehi, the inner dweller is not affected.

00:06:57.173 --> 00:07:03.403
What is affected is the transactional reality, that type of reality you do have to face.

00:07:03.863 --> 00:07:12.517
Shri Krishna is saying that the body and the mind is the one that does things it's not necessarily the dehi, the inner dweller, your true self.

00:07:12.788 --> 00:07:20.148
So therefore do not believe that the Atma is going to be subjected to the deeds that you do.

00:07:21.040 --> 00:07:22.630
It will remain unaffected.

00:07:23.497 --> 00:07:25.927
Its only purpose is that you should realize it.

00:07:26.137 --> 00:07:27.778
That's the only purpose of the Atma.

00:07:27.877 --> 00:07:37.728
If anyone still believes that they are the do of action and they are duties to be performed, as mentioned in verse 19, they are not enlightened beings.

00:07:37.951 --> 00:07:39.471
They are still deluded.

00:07:39.812 --> 00:07:45.752
They are still under the false understanding of what the true self is.

00:07:46.339 --> 00:07:48.980
Actually they haven't realized the Self very simply.

00:07:49.430 --> 00:07:51.470
They haven't realized this Brahman.

00:07:51.870 --> 00:07:53.572
This Brahman that is their reality.

00:07:53.603 --> 00:07:54.822
It is who they are.

00:07:55.386 --> 00:07:59.555
No one can deny this is what Shri Krishna is trying to point out too.

00:07:59.713 --> 00:08:07.723
If we still see people who say, I have to do this action, I have to do this ritual because I need to gain this.

00:08:08.009 --> 00:08:09.180
They are still deluded.

00:08:10.079 --> 00:08:17.339
They still do not understand that it is understanding this Brahman, which is more important.

00:08:18.254 --> 00:08:21.105
Which should be the task one should always go towards.

00:08:21.196 --> 00:08:40.841
Adi Sankara ji makes it clear that an enlightened being who fully understands that they are this imperishable Atman, this imperishable Brahman, if they understand this and they are the seeker of liberation, they are qualified for renunciation of all rights and duties, according to the Vedas.

00:08:41.048 --> 00:08:52.414
What's interesting is that if one has realized Brahman and one is now liberated, how are they going to do the rites and rituals that are needed to be done before?

00:08:53.201 --> 00:09:01.952
Before the rights from rituals were done so you could gain punya, actions which reaped benefits, that advanced you spiritually.

00:09:02.592 --> 00:09:11.808
Now once you know everything, once you know that One and that you are this One, how are you going to perform those rites and rituals?

00:09:12.291 --> 00:09:16.821
Because you know that it is only the body and the mind that is committing to those rituals.

00:09:17.030 --> 00:09:18.051
It's the senses.

00:09:18.321 --> 00:09:25.856
The mouth is chanting the mantras, the hands is moving the thali, the mind is remembering the mantras.

00:09:26.524 --> 00:09:27.453
It's all thought.

00:09:28.510 --> 00:09:34.798
Therefore there's no need for a liberated being to do those things, they can renounce those.

00:09:35.078 --> 00:09:47.471
And in fact, it may even appear that they still conduct those rites and rituals, they may still conduct havans and may still conduct pujas and worship, but they understand what they are worshiping.

00:09:47.711 --> 00:09:49.211
That's the difference also.

00:09:49.341 --> 00:10:00.274
So when they renounce, it's not about being perfect in your rites and rituals, they know that the real purpose of this is that they are worshiping really themselves.

00:10:01.443 --> 00:10:02.313
That's what it is.

00:10:03.423 --> 00:10:04.384
They are the self.

00:10:04.594 --> 00:10:05.833
They are not affected.

00:10:06.264 --> 00:10:09.063
Brahman is not affected by our rites and rituals.

00:10:09.385 --> 00:10:11.495
Brahman is changeless.

00:10:12.549 --> 00:10:16.840
If Brahman changed its opinion, then it cannot be Brahman.

00:10:17.113 --> 00:10:18.610
Then it's subject to change.

00:10:18.940 --> 00:10:26.830
Therefore, Brahman would be asat but because Brahman is Sat it is not influenced by our worldly actions.

00:10:27.268 --> 00:10:29.217
We have to grasp this understanding.

00:10:29.530 --> 00:10:36.207
I know I'm repeating some things, but it really is difficult to understand and comprehend.

00:10:36.907 --> 00:10:46.926
I myself have had to go through so much work to understand this and right now, while I'm going through the Bhagavad Gita, I'm learning so many new things.

00:10:47.326 --> 00:11:10.147
I'm getting new insights that I never got before, because when we've spent time on something, when we don't do things for leisure or to get ourselves away from being bored, then it requires us to focus and with focus comes great understanding, especially when it comes to spirituality.

00:11:11.017 --> 00:11:31.105
Like Arjuna, we have to make sure we understand this wisdom, as it is said in the Upanishads that 'It is to be realized to the mind alone.' The mind is purified by the knowledge of Berman in the scriptures and the Master, with self restraint of one senses, one can be ready to realize Brahman.

00:11:31.394 --> 00:11:33.345
So everything does come through the mind.

00:11:33.451 --> 00:11:37.085
It is a mind that begins to understand that it is Brahman.

00:11:37.134 --> 00:11:43.085
This is what Adi Sankara ji is saying that one cannot think that one can escape the mind.

00:11:43.134 --> 00:11:45.095
No, the mind is required.

00:11:45.995 --> 00:11:48.625
Without the mind, we do not come across thought.

00:11:49.355 --> 00:11:52.325
Without thought, we can not come across insight.

00:11:52.575 --> 00:11:54.875
Without insight, we cannot know Brahman.

00:11:55.725 --> 00:12:01.855
It is that insight created by thought, caused by thought that we'd get to know Brahman.

00:12:01.875 --> 00:12:03.524
That we get to know the formless.

00:12:03.878 --> 00:12:06.488
This is an important thing to know.

00:12:07.168 --> 00:12:24.179
Yes, you use the mind, but you then have to drop the mind because at the end, when you understand everything, when you understand that you're Brahman, then you can just allow the mind to function as it needs to function.

00:12:24.493 --> 00:12:28.024
There's no need to feel obligated to do anything.

00:12:28.549 --> 00:12:29.809
There's no obligation.

00:12:30.163 --> 00:12:36.482
One does need to restrain one senses, and this is very important and I will continue on why.

00:12:36.955 --> 00:12:49.174
If one is still hankering for desires, hunkering for food, smells food and then loses all sensibilities and all restraint, then they are simply too full to think of Brahman.

00:12:49.794 --> 00:13:05.408
If one is attracted by the smell of nice food, sometimes if I smell a dessert being made, a cake being made and I lose all of my senses because the mind acknowledges that now this body is going to eat this food.

00:13:05.445 --> 00:13:08.924
The body starts feeling great, I see the food, I'm going to eat that food.

00:13:09.043 --> 00:13:12.528
If we're too full, how are we going to be spending time with Brahman?

00:13:12.941 --> 00:13:26.739
We'll be thinking about drinking some Peptac or any thing that can get rid of acid reflux or gas has been built up because of overeating because our desires haven't stopped.

00:13:27.446 --> 00:13:29.668
Our hunger for food has not stopped.

00:13:29.668 --> 00:13:32.149
We've not been able to restrain ourselves and say, you know what?

00:13:32.239 --> 00:13:33.678
I need to control my body.

00:13:33.979 --> 00:13:40.109
I need to control what I eat, because if I'm unhealthy, then I cannot sit and think about Brahman.

00:13:40.475 --> 00:13:43.525
One has to always keep one's body fit and healthy.

00:13:43.811 --> 00:13:47.979
We have to keep our body and our senses in restraint.

00:13:48.232 --> 00:13:49.923
It's very important that we do that.

00:13:50.986 --> 00:13:52.256
It's a practice.

00:13:52.652 --> 00:13:54.062
It's not going to happen overnight.

00:13:54.062 --> 00:13:55.591
It doesn't mean that you don't eat food.

00:13:55.754 --> 00:13:58.754
You eat just enough so your body can continue.

00:14:00.075 --> 00:14:06.164
Yes, sometimes we eat the food that we enjoy eating, eat them, but don't get carried away with the enjoyment.

00:14:08.894 --> 00:14:13.134
Don't get to the point where you start dreaming about that food tomorrow.

00:14:14.304 --> 00:14:17.865
Oh, that food yesterday was so great, I can't wait to have it again.

00:14:18.115 --> 00:14:19.014
Guess what's happened.

00:14:19.014 --> 00:14:20.485
The mind has wandered away.

00:14:22.554 --> 00:14:28.825
The mind is now completely at the helm of the body and the senses.

00:14:30.504 --> 00:14:46.429
Therefore the saints and the sages of the past and of the present guide us to really focus on restraining our senses and by doing that, we're able to focus more time on realizing Brahman.

00:14:47.200 --> 00:14:49.929
Sometimes we say, God wanted this to happen.

00:14:50.889 --> 00:14:54.129
God wanted, no, those are wrong beliefs.

00:14:55.029 --> 00:15:00.746
They may help in the beginning, but eventually you have to discard those beliefs because they don't mean anything.

00:15:01.697 --> 00:15:03.376
Brahman does not do anything.

00:15:03.496 --> 00:15:06.547
If Brahman did, then it wouldn't be Changeless.

00:15:09.032 --> 00:15:10.442
That means Brahman changes.

00:15:10.902 --> 00:15:18.778
If you pray to God and you pray to Brahman, and you say Brahman get rid of my problems and Brahman gets rid of your problems.

00:15:19.107 --> 00:15:23.788
Then that means Brahman is subject to change by what you are wishing.

00:15:24.268 --> 00:15:27.798
But really Brahman within us does not wish upon anything.

00:15:27.996 --> 00:15:32.491
We have to always discern that the body and mind is wishing something, not Brahman.

00:15:32.889 --> 00:15:42.818
When I'm praying to Brahman to get something, I'm actually just praying to myself and it's my body and mind, that's going to create the action.

00:15:43.119 --> 00:15:54.196
Not Brahman Adi Sankara ji gets even more direct: only someone who believes they are different to himself will go and say, do this act, go and kill someone.

00:15:54.645 --> 00:16:12.494
They believe there is a difference, but here Krishna is not physically talking to Krishna or to Arjuna, it is the same Atman, the same Purusha, although seemingly one is speaking and the other is listening.

00:16:13.147 --> 00:16:17.268
Krishna and Arjuna in Krishna's understanding are one and the same.

00:16:18.347 --> 00:16:19.658
It is the same Brahman.

00:16:19.996 --> 00:16:23.274
Arjuna doesn't know this, but Krishna knows.

00:16:24.394 --> 00:16:32.551
It's the same Atma the same atma that spoke in Krishna back then is the same Atma within me, within you.

00:16:33.301 --> 00:16:35.788
That is either speaking or listening to this.

00:16:38.187 --> 00:16:39.207
It's not changed.

00:16:39.610 --> 00:16:40.900
The Atman has remained.

00:16:41.222 --> 00:16:43.352
Verse 22.

00:16:43.773 --> 00:16:56.700
Just as the nara human being throws away old garments that are tattered and worn,so the immortal dehi leaves one material body and simply moves on to another.

00:16:57.227 --> 00:17:01.905
This is a very popular verse in the Gita and can be interpreted in many ways.

00:17:01.966 --> 00:17:05.464
You hear people talk about this constantly.

00:17:05.560 --> 00:17:12.729
Firstly one was fundamentally believe in reincarnation to entertain this idea in this verse specifically.

00:17:13.239 --> 00:17:24.941
It's very obvious that once the body ages it has to let go of itself, it cannot function any further, our mind may start withering away, we're not as fast anymore.

00:17:25.421 --> 00:17:35.681
And today, if you want to compare things, people just throw out clothes because they're out of fashion or just by wanting more clothes.

00:17:36.131 --> 00:17:43.711
I tend to ask this question that if you always going out buying things, how do you ever find time for realization or spirituality.

00:17:44.248 --> 00:17:53.827
If you constantly having to buy a new top because it's out of fashion this week, it takes time to look for something, then you have to purchase it, then you're going to wear it.

00:17:54.097 --> 00:18:00.347
And in fact, before that you've been,thinking about where to wear it and which event you're going to go and wear it.

00:18:00.567 --> 00:18:03.978
At the end of the day, how can we find time for realization.

00:18:04.383 --> 00:18:13.566
Likewise, we have to understand that desires are with the body and in the end, this body's going to be thrown into the fire or thrown into the ground.

00:18:14.096 --> 00:18:19.215
Nobody values the body once it is lifeless and especially post funeral.

00:18:19.685 --> 00:18:28.333
All one becomes is symbols in a gravestone or etched in memories of our loved ones that's all that remains.

00:18:29.573 --> 00:18:32.843
Therefore, we need to understand what is this material body?

00:18:33.633 --> 00:18:37.232
It is simply energy and this energy will always be transformed.

00:18:37.843 --> 00:18:46.633
It will always take some other form and another way to think of this,, clothes example is clothes may be new, only worn once and thrown out.

00:18:47.272 --> 00:18:54.618
We can see this in this example that some people die young, seemingly healthy and they die with a cardiac arrest.

00:18:54.699 --> 00:19:00.769
So many footballers fit and healthy, we hear about them just dying of a cardiac arrest.

00:19:00.979 --> 00:19:04.358
It happens or something tragic happens to a baby.

00:19:04.358 --> 00:19:07.093
We hear about cot deaths that happen.

00:19:07.528 --> 00:19:09.239
Or children get cancer.

00:19:09.751 --> 00:19:20.734
How does Krishna married this up with this verse that once clothes get worn out, normally when clothes are tattered and they're ripped, we throw them out.

00:19:21.000 --> 00:19:30.868
If you think deeply about it, we then have to accept the concept of the Jiva, that simply the current body was unfit to carry out the karma that is remaining.

00:19:31.136 --> 00:19:39.653
Somewhere, there is still some form of action that is remaining and that this body was not fit for the rest of the journey.

00:19:39.987 --> 00:19:47.446
So it has to find it another body to become fit again to complete the karma that needs to be completed.

00:19:47.807 --> 00:19:55.958
Or you could turn around and say that the body became unfit now for realization, therefore it has to go to a new body.

00:19:56.171 --> 00:20:10.361
This is quite harsh in a way I think when we say things like this, because we have to really divorce the idea that it is the body that goes and it is the mind that goes.

00:20:10.361 --> 00:20:13.300
That basically that what remains is the eternal self.

00:20:13.300 --> 00:20:13.540
Yeah.

00:20:13.570 --> 00:20:23.570
We can embrace that, but to embrace the idea that this body and mind is not going to remain is quite tough for us, but the Jiva that does carry on.

00:20:23.721 --> 00:20:35.790
In a way, your mind, your memories and all those things, your conditioning, your thoughts that you've had, all those do remain and they still continue on through the Jiva.

00:20:36.287 --> 00:20:43.461
When the Jiva understands its true self, then the Jiva understands that actually all these conditionings are not me.

00:20:43.681 --> 00:20:45.691
The Jiva is what changes everything.

00:20:45.961 --> 00:20:50.968
You could see the Jiva as a cosmic mind or the unmanifest mind.

00:20:52.448 --> 00:21:02.895
The mind that you currently have is the manifest mind and that is the one that will understand what is Brahman and therefore have realization.

00:21:03.705 --> 00:21:18.445
By understanding that some people go young, we may understand that basically the body just not fit to carry out the desires that that Jiva has remaining and the karma that is accumulated in that Jiva.

00:21:18.700 --> 00:21:21.480
What is new and what is old is always perspective.

00:21:21.613 --> 00:21:27.175
For example, someone wears a Louis Vuitton scarf for five years and finds that now it's old.

00:21:27.296 --> 00:21:34.096
There's no need to wear it anymore, and they give it to charity, they give it to the Goodwill store or salvation army.

00:21:34.596 --> 00:21:47.826
But someone who will go into that store, into that charity shop or into the Goodwill store or the salvation army store, they will see that same scarf and see it as new, they got a new scarf.

00:21:47.982 --> 00:21:51.643
So when they go to their family and friends, they will say, oh, look at the new scarf I've got.

00:21:52.063 --> 00:21:55.256
They're not going to say, oh yeah, I picked it up at the Goodwill store.

00:21:55.604 --> 00:21:58.228
They gonna say, look at this brand new Louis Vuitton scarf.

00:21:59.228 --> 00:22:02.518
What is new and what is old is always according to our perspective.

00:22:02.917 --> 00:22:04.837
It's very subjective in that way.

00:22:05.474 --> 00:22:11.625
Remember the body decays or it is burned into ashes, that is the nature of the body.

00:22:11.767 --> 00:22:13.267
It is subject to be destroyed.

00:22:14.317 --> 00:22:18.787
But the atma is not the body because it is neither born nor does it die.

00:22:18.916 --> 00:22:23.926
The atma can not be destroyed, Brahman cannot be destroyed in any way, it's just not possible.

00:22:24.201 --> 00:22:29.901
Another way to see is that the eternal self is infused in all forms that appear and disappear.

00:22:30.277 --> 00:22:37.237
Therefore it never truly leaves when the forms disappear and doesn't arrive, when these forms appear.

00:22:37.807 --> 00:22:39.696
It simply remains as Is-ness.

00:22:40.676 --> 00:22:50.111
It pervades everywhere, but doesn't necessarily get influenced by what forms are in front of us and what forms disappear.

00:22:50.471 --> 00:22:57.281
It just remains the immortal dehi, that immortal self, that immortal Brahman, there is no death at all for that.

00:22:57.511 --> 00:23:01.892
And for the deha the body, there is no survival, even for the fittest.

00:23:02.048 --> 00:23:05.828
Let's understand this the immortal dehi, there is no death at all.

00:23:05.965 --> 00:23:11.576
And for the deha, the body, there is no survival, even for the fittest.

00:23:11.846 --> 00:23:13.526
Now we get to verse 23.

00:23:13.888 --> 00:23:18.509
That indestructible being cannot be cut by weapons or burned by fire.

00:23:18.655 --> 00:23:22.622
Water cannot make it wet, and the wind cannot cause it to wither.

00:23:22.898 --> 00:23:31.336
What we need to understand is that this indestructible being this being that is partless yeah and formless, how can it be cut with a sword?

00:23:31.568 --> 00:23:36.023
Being partless and formless, how can it be reduced to ashes with fire.

00:23:36.391 --> 00:23:41.191
Being indestructable and formless, how can it be eroded away with water?

00:23:41.396 --> 00:23:50.951
Being formless and without elements, even air cannot wither it or dry it, or dehydrate it as it is not made from any substance.

00:23:51.693 --> 00:23:57.663
We must remember with this verse and as mentioned in the last podcast, the self cannot negate itself.

00:23:57.784 --> 00:24:03.344
You can negate these four elements here, but you cannot negate Brahman.

00:24:04.010 --> 00:24:06.451
Brahman remains apart from that negation.

00:24:06.826 --> 00:24:09.636
Whenever you negate, you end up going to Brahman.

00:24:10.354 --> 00:24:16.038
So for something to be real, to be true, like Brahman it has to be beyond negation.

00:24:16.038 --> 00:24:23.915
That's how you see it and if you think about it, can awareness itself, the awareness within you can it negate itself?

00:24:24.461 --> 00:24:30.271
Try, it's impossible try and negate awareness because what remains?

00:24:30.781 --> 00:24:31.442
Awareness.

00:24:31.981 --> 00:24:32.852
Consciousness.

00:24:33.321 --> 00:24:37.271
As it is the self, the atma that objectifies everything else.

00:24:37.540 --> 00:24:39.851
It cannot be objectified itself.

00:24:40.101 --> 00:24:43.340
Brahman can see everything else as objects.

00:24:43.941 --> 00:24:49.191
It can perceive others as objects, but it itself can not be an object.

00:24:49.349 --> 00:24:54.690
It can be aware of objects, but it cannot be any object.

00:24:55.015 --> 00:24:59.092
The Atma or Brahman is a subject of every object.

00:24:59.169 --> 00:25:00.848
It is consciousness itself.

00:25:01.868 --> 00:25:08.199
So we have to understand that it's through consciousness, through Brahman, that objects are there.

00:25:08.605 --> 00:25:12.479
So to understand this further, remember the Atma never burns.

00:25:12.509 --> 00:25:14.588
Brahman never burns, only the body.

00:25:15.489 --> 00:25:17.818
Brahman cannot drown, only the body.

00:25:18.174 --> 00:25:20.125
Brahman can never become dehydrated.

00:25:20.605 --> 00:25:21.325
Only the body.

00:25:21.605 --> 00:25:32.259
The five elements are used here in the way, with the sword being the objects of the earth followed by the obvious fire, water and air and akash or space isn't mentioned here.

00:25:32.963 --> 00:25:40.394
But remember, the body is contained within that space and space is not entirely empty, but actually contains atoms.

00:25:40.577 --> 00:25:44.867
There is form there, whilst theAtma or Brahman is formless.

00:25:44.999 --> 00:25:53.528
Even though we need to consider that atoms also have an aspect of form, even though we're looking at space really there's something there.

00:25:53.701 --> 00:25:57.415
A simple example to use is the reflection of yourself in the mirror.

00:25:57.516 --> 00:26:00.576
The reflection doesn't have any separate existence.

00:26:00.732 --> 00:26:03.282
It cannot come out of the mirror and harm you.

00:26:03.472 --> 00:26:06.113
If you think so then it's all in your mind.

00:26:06.395 --> 00:26:10.355
So the reflection is asat, while you are Sat, real.

00:26:10.566 --> 00:26:14.226
Likewise, these elements are asat and Brahman is real.

00:26:14.366 --> 00:26:25.942
Let us understand this more that if you suddenly came out of the mirror, your reflection, it will be scary, but also it's all in your mind.

00:26:26.096 --> 00:26:27.986
You know the reflection is not you.

00:26:28.556 --> 00:26:33.796
You know this, if your reflection started doing something you weren't doing, it will be freaky.

00:26:34.148 --> 00:26:38.957
But you know that the reflection is completely doing what you want it to do because you're doing it.

00:26:39.131 --> 00:26:46.830
Likewise, we need to understand that this Brahman is real and that everything else is a reflection of that Brahman.

00:26:47.401 --> 00:26:47.941
That's all.

00:26:48.263 --> 00:26:55.048
It seemingly has forms, but really it's that undying awareness with you.

00:26:55.231 --> 00:26:56.477
Then verse 24.

00:26:56.641 --> 00:27:05.773
This Sanatana 'Immortal' being cannot be cut into parts, destroyed by fire drowned by water or dried by wind.

00:27:06.037 --> 00:27:11.797
It is nitya 'everlasting', subtler the matter, always standing and exists forever.

00:27:12.034 --> 00:27:19.682
Again, there's a bit of repetition but it is to make us understand that you have to separate what is Sat and what is Asat.

00:27:19.836 --> 00:27:26.230
So the Sanatana, the Immortal, the eternal, this Brahman, cannot be cut into any parts because it is formless.

00:27:26.259 --> 00:27:27.369
It is partless.

00:27:27.593 --> 00:27:28.363
What is formless?

00:27:28.363 --> 00:27:29.363
How can you cut it?

00:27:29.537 --> 00:27:32.874
If something has no form at all, how can it be cut?

00:27:33.023 --> 00:27:37.152
It cannot be destroyed by fire because it has no form to be reduced to ashes.

00:27:37.368 --> 00:27:48.810
It cannot be drowned by water, nor dried by the wind, summarizing and yet bringing firm conviction into making us understand the Purusha, the Self -Brahman.

00:27:49.211 --> 00:27:52.480
This is what this is doing, solidifying our understanding.

00:27:52.901 --> 00:27:54.851
So we do not enter delusion again.

00:27:55.631 --> 00:27:56.740
Right now, we may get it.

00:27:56.740 --> 00:27:57.730
We may understand it.

00:27:58.044 --> 00:28:05.798
We may know that it's obvious that we are Brahman, but when you're in a challenging situation, will you still remember this?

00:28:07.239 --> 00:28:09.098
That is what we need to understand.

00:28:09.638 --> 00:28:10.118
Yes.

00:28:10.148 --> 00:28:17.346
You may respond to an event that is challenging, but you will always have in the back of your mind, that I'm not the doer.

00:28:20.056 --> 00:28:23.211
Brahman never does, I'm just watching action happen.

00:28:23.397 --> 00:28:37.654
Adi Sankara Ji actually warns us by informing us that Shri Krishna uses similar phrases because the intention is to ensure that the yet not realized person begins to manifest understanding and comprehension of the immortal Self.

00:28:37.845 --> 00:28:42.914
That this immortal being cannot be reincarnated, nor does it go through samsara.

00:28:43.025 --> 00:28:48.080
It is the complete end of the cycle of births and deaths.

00:28:48.320 --> 00:28:51.171
Therefore, there is no real repetition going on.

00:28:51.249 --> 00:28:58.568
Here we can understand that there's no repetition in terms of the knowledge it's to just reinforce what we need to understand.

00:28:58.855 --> 00:29:07.959
We may have a question when it comes to Brahman that, well, if it's partless, can it be zero or empty, Shunya or the void?

00:29:08.163 --> 00:29:16.028
Actually, no, it can't be because it is self existent and self evident, with it being self evident.

00:29:16.058 --> 00:29:21.046
That means that it can't be shunya, it can't be completely empty.

00:29:21.220 --> 00:29:25.990
We know that what seemingly is empty can actually be dissected further.

00:29:26.256 --> 00:29:27.445
We see space.

00:29:27.715 --> 00:29:36.385
We cannot see atoms, but through microscope you could see atoms and with the aid of the microscope, you may be able to cut that atom and dissect it further.

00:29:36.766 --> 00:29:42.858
But with Brahman that is not possible because Brahman is self evident upon itself.

00:29:43.096 --> 00:29:44.776
You are the evidence of Brahman.

00:29:44.884 --> 00:29:46.324
It's obvious there is Brahman.

00:29:46.622 --> 00:29:48.332
So therefore it cannot be empty.

00:29:48.932 --> 00:29:52.316
It can seem like it's empty, but it's not.

00:29:52.788 --> 00:29:59.163
It just simply doesn't have a form and because of this, it cannot be cut, nor burned, nor dried, nor drowned.

00:29:59.355 --> 00:30:06.268
What's used here is the word 'nitya,' which means everlasting timeless and this implies that it is beyond time.

00:30:06.580 --> 00:30:14.383
Therefore must be beyond space and also space or akash is in regards to the world, the universe that we see.

00:30:14.599 --> 00:30:16.759
Anything empty, we call it space.

00:30:17.103 --> 00:30:18.333
It seems everlasting.

00:30:18.603 --> 00:30:25.963
So when you look into the night sky, you think that is everlasting, there's no end to it but actually it does have an end.

00:30:26.306 --> 00:30:35.041
Brahman is consciousness and consciousness does contain space, we need to understand that consciousness can operate in space.

00:30:35.185 --> 00:30:40.715
The atma, this Brahman exists forever and its reach is beyond comprehension.

00:30:40.915 --> 00:30:44.965
This is what happens because of it being everlasting and timeless.

00:30:45.236 --> 00:30:46.836
We struggle to comprehend it.

00:30:47.201 --> 00:30:54.112
We struggle to comprehend how consciousness can still operate in space, but space can never become consciousness.

00:30:54.478 --> 00:31:03.721
Therefore it leads to Krishna's second sentence that it is everlasting subtler than matter, always standing as in stable and exists forever.

00:31:03.895 --> 00:31:06.375
Or alternatively, pervading everywhere.

00:31:06.588 --> 00:31:11.402
This Brahman because it is pervading everywhere, it is stable and cannot move.

00:31:11.821 --> 00:31:16.622
You can't move Brahman because he pervades everywhere.

00:31:17.771 --> 00:31:25.715
With the word sanatana one establishes the fact that it isn't brought into being by cause or by an effect of something.

00:31:25.972 --> 00:31:30.659
Nor by any force of nature, nor element of nature, it is beyond all that.

00:31:30.856 --> 00:31:39.708
It's beyond ancient, timeless and by stating it is subtler than matter, it's confirming that the atma is consciousness.

00:31:39.944 --> 00:31:43.167
This is seen for ourselves when we turn our mind inwards.

00:31:43.412 --> 00:31:56.525
Again, by negating what we see and perceive, we're able to go into that process, when we negate everything, and eventually what will remain is our awareness, our consciousness.

00:31:56.577 --> 00:32:02.981
Once we understand this, and we continue to turn our mind inwards, the stronger the understanding will be.

00:32:03.190 --> 00:32:10.930
Once we understand this self, then we understand very simply that Arjuna does not need to be in sorrow because the Self is permanent.

00:32:11.491 --> 00:32:12.721
The Self is eternal.

00:32:12.781 --> 00:32:17.127
This Brahman is eternal, it's everlasting, and it is the true self.

00:32:17.157 --> 00:32:19.978
It is the true being in everyone.

00:32:19.998 --> 00:32:36.457
For himself, for the people on this side and for the people that he will battle with and kill eventually they are all this Brahman, therefore being subtler than matter, because it is beyond our comprehension, of seeing, of perception.

00:32:36.702 --> 00:32:42.616
It is beyond change itself and while matter is subject to change, just like the body he perceives.

00:32:42.787 --> 00:32:44.136
The bodies will come and go.

00:32:44.287 --> 00:32:45.457
They will change.

00:32:46.416 --> 00:32:48.967
They will change its form when they die.

00:32:49.297 --> 00:32:54.057
But the thing is this Brahman is beyond that change, it's subtler than matter.

00:32:54.507 --> 00:32:57.557
In fact, sometimes they say subtler than the subtle.

00:32:57.896 --> 00:33:01.346
It is beyond our comprehension.

00:33:01.450 --> 00:33:07.839
Therefore, yes, we use the mind, but it is then awareness, that brings us to that understanding.

00:33:08.125 --> 00:33:09.536
Then verse 25.

00:33:09.752 --> 00:33:15.363
That undying individual is invisible, inconceivable, and unchangeable.

00:33:16.202 --> 00:33:21.121
Therefore, you should not despair at the passing-away of the bodily form.

00:33:21.351 --> 00:33:25.115
Again, reminding us of this formless being and that we are Brahman.

00:33:25.565 --> 00:33:29.412
We are told here that it is un-manifest and invisible.

00:33:29.714 --> 00:33:31.365
The senses cannot perceive it.

00:33:31.605 --> 00:33:34.005
Therefore it cannot be turned into an object.

00:33:34.875 --> 00:33:38.332
If our senses can't pick it up, it just cannot be objectified.

00:33:38.362 --> 00:33:40.491
Simply our mind cannot do anything with it.

00:33:40.622 --> 00:33:45.711
Our mind cannot do anything with awareness actually, because the mind is an object of awareness.

00:33:45.875 --> 00:33:47.795
This formless being is inconceivable.

00:33:47.898 --> 00:33:51.548
It is beyond the senses and it cannot be the object of inference.

00:33:51.672 --> 00:33:56.142
It cannot be the object of inference because this formless self cannot be objectified.

00:33:56.338 --> 00:34:02.545
It is self-evident when we truly experienced our true self and this atma is completely unchangeable.

00:34:02.670 --> 00:34:05.369
It is not like milk that can be churned into butter.

00:34:05.453 --> 00:34:07.614
It cannot be modified in any way.

00:34:07.809 --> 00:34:12.045
We have to understand that it's not like food that can go from raw to being cooked.

00:34:12.222 --> 00:34:13.632
It is not like that either.

00:34:14.041 --> 00:34:19.021
Therefore, this atma doesn't go through emotions of happiness or grief.

00:34:19.228 --> 00:34:20.878
It is forever changeless.

00:34:21.298 --> 00:34:26.114
How can something Nirguna'attribute-less' go through any change.

00:34:26.623 --> 00:34:29.173
Only some thing with attributes can change.

00:34:30.103 --> 00:34:37.851
We've established this in the previous episode, therefore it's impossible that Nirguna Brahman can change at all.

00:34:38.309 --> 00:34:46.523
Therefore by establishing this Truth to us, Krishna rightfully directs Arjuna to understand that there is no need to feel despair.

00:34:46.860 --> 00:34:48.570
There's no need for him to feel sorrow.

00:34:48.601 --> 00:34:56.141
There's no need for him to be disturbed because he has to understand that he is not killing anyone.

00:34:56.547 --> 00:34:59.898
He is the atman, the self and the self is not the doer.

00:35:00.057 --> 00:35:01.097
Berman is not the doer.

00:35:01.210 --> 00:35:03.489
Brahman is within the other people too.

00:35:03.914 --> 00:35:11.451
With this knowledge, with this wisdom, he should be able to understand that those are not bodies that I'm going to be killing.

00:35:11.733 --> 00:35:18.820
It is only seemingly the bodies that they have, but really they are the eternal Brahman.

00:35:19.360 --> 00:35:20.510
Brahman cannot die.

00:35:21.199 --> 00:35:23.000
Brahman cannot be killed by the sword.

00:35:23.659 --> 00:35:33.391
This is to reemphasize to Arjuna to understand that he is Brahman not the body, and therefore the body will kill another body in this war.

00:35:33.641 --> 00:35:36.612
But Brahman cannot kill Brahman, simple as that.

00:35:36.768 --> 00:35:38.748
The self is beyond birth and death.

00:35:39.259 --> 00:35:49.021
Therefore Arjuna should not feel the loss of those he respects and honors, as it is only their material form that is facing a demise.

00:35:49.742 --> 00:35:51.172
He has to understand this.

00:35:51.525 --> 00:35:55.304
That it's only atoms that are just going to be transformed or transferred.

00:35:55.710 --> 00:35:57.150
They won't truly die.

00:35:57.929 --> 00:36:13.420
The body will continue in another form or way, in another form or in another, rupa but the people that he respects and honors and loves, they will always be because they are this Brahman, the same Brahman that he is.

00:36:13.800 --> 00:36:35.496
So by the knowledge of knowing what is Sat - 'real' and by knowing what is asat - ' unreal', Arjuna knows that only the material is the doer, but his true self that is indestructable, inconceivable, timeless, changeless, unmanifest, eternal, stable, stillness, formless and partless is never the doer.

00:36:35.536 --> 00:36:41.507
Nor does it cause anything to occur, therefore, grieving for matter is silly.

00:36:42.376 --> 00:36:49.233
As the body will only have a new form, it will always have a form, no matter what happens.

00:36:49.460 --> 00:36:56.934
This ends this episode and we just went through verses 21 to verses 25.

00:36:57.039 --> 00:36:58.436
Thank you very much for listening.

00:36:58.626 --> 00:37:16.161
Remember, a new episode is uploaded every Sunday and do follow my social media channels specifically TikTok because the videos I do there are sometimes not of this podcast and the account details are in the videos description and show notes below.

00:37:16.192 --> 00:37:21.592
Please do rate and review this podcast on apple podcasts and also on overcast.

00:37:21.922 --> 00:37:23.594
I will greatly appreciate it.

00:37:24.105 --> 00:37:25.514
Thank you very much for listening.

00:37:25.561 --> 00:37:26.282
Take care.

00:37:26.311 --> 00:37:27.181
Stay safe.

00:37:27.512 --> 00:37:27.931
Bye.